Fresh Baked Goods

Product Offering

Our baked goods are made by one of the most reputable bakery houses in Lancaster County, located in Leola, Pennsylvania. For generations, the Byers family has been baking traditional whoopie pies, shoo fly pies, cookies, and more! They have physical market stands throughout Lancaster County, where they sell wonderful products, many of which are displayed below. Now you can get a taste of the finest baked goods delivered overnight to your door.

Order online here or call 1.800.863.6109.

Whoopie Pies by the Dozen

Our Price: $18.00

The most delicious, moist whoopie pies from Lancaster County PA. We now offer Chocolate, Red Velvet, Peanut Butter, Chocolate Chips and Pumpkin. If you like any flavor specifically, please specify the quantity

Montgomery Pie (8" Pie)

Our Price: $14.99

A Pennsylvania Dutch deep dish pie that is made with a mild lemon base and a yellow cake topping with a lemon flavor. An Amish Dutch traditional pie at its best. You will be hooked forever once you try this pie.

Pecan Pie

Our Price: $14.99

Our pecan pie is made with the finest ingredients and is one of our very best sellers. Order early for the holidays. Your family and friends will be very pleased!

Apple Pie

Our Price: $14.95

A delicious apple pie with cinnamon and a delicious pastry shell

Sugar Cookies (12 Cookies per bag)

Our Price: $14.99

Delicious soft sugar cookies made with fresh buttermilk. Great for the holiday season. This generation of Byers bakers uses this family recipe. Each cookie is four to five inches in diameter.